Welcome to the AAA Review Archives

Hi all!

Firstly, welcome to our little site.

We are an evergrowing group of friends and music lovers who use this site as a catalog of sorts. New reviews are supposed to be uploaded after our weekly meeting on Tuesday nights, though website construction is not any of our professions so this schedule is wishful thinking at its best. Below you can find quick links to hop around our page and check out all the fun stuff we’ve been listening to since we started this in 2024!

 

Premise & Metrics - The what, why, and how of our convoluted evaluation system and how it came to be

 

Browse - This contains the entire collections of albums we’ve reviewed in chronological order and divided by participant. Easiest way of just browsing what has been done and what currently on the chopping block

 

Comparator - This is the far more technical compilation of our metadata for each album helpful for comparative inquiries between albums

 

Comments - AAA is constantly changing and we love to get exposure to new stuff so if you have any comments or recommendations, feel free to reach out to us!

 

Thanks again for stopping by

Enjoy your time here

 


PREMISE


 

AAA (or Triple A as we'll refer to it in discussion) is not our first attempt at an album review format. For a few years before this platform, we would meet every three or four days to talk about albums we shared with eachother and ranked them on an S through F tier list (if you were every curious about the background of the homepage, all of those coveres are albums that were done for this first iteration of the group). And while this "worked" for a time, I'm sure the dear reader could imagine all sorts of drawbacks inherent in this system. Below we've expanded on two of the biggest issues that ended our review group when we left college.

- Firstly, and most glaring was the timeline. The first iteration took place while we were in college and so we wanted to get as many albums done in a given semester as possible. But in hindsight, three days to render a decision on an album is hardly fair and often ended up with a skewed ranking in favour of artists we were already familiar with as opposed to using the meetings to showcase new artists and explore to edges of music. When you compound that with the fact that we were all full time students it was a miracle for an album would get more than a handful of listens by everyone before it brough before the jury for a verdict. It was unnecissarily stressful on the participants and didn't let albums really show us what they had to offer; it was really a lose-lose.

- Secondly was the idea of using a tier list system to compare music in the first place. Trying to compare music across time, space, genre, and intent with a single letter was unneccisarily restrictive and led several conversations that didn't go any further than "I liked X less that Y so I have to give it a lower ranking." To be frank, more of the time was spent justifying how we felt about tha album before giving our ranking than was spent analysing the music and appreciating a piece of art. And because most conversations enevitably turned towards personal opinion exclusively, it was soul crushing to bring an album that meant something to you to the group only to have people refuse to engage with it on the basis it wasn't for them without any further substantiation.

But after some time away from the old system, and despite all it's flaws, we missed getting to talk about music with our friends. It's what we're passionate about, and to be honest it was juts plain fun to sit down every week and just get to hang out. And with that the new and improved AAA was born and continues to this day, every changing and ever improving.

 


METRICS


 

Blank review wheel for demonstration purposes

The chart to the left is really the heart of AAA. Broadly, the review chart can be divided into four quadrants highlighted in the furthest most ring: depth dealing with an albums content and intent, emothion for how the music feels while listening, energy focused on the impact of a particular artist on their work, and sound which deals with the musicianship of the album more broadly. It should be noted, if not obvious already, that these are vague categories and often times conversation will readily bob back and forth between all of these as we attempt to discuss the music and really only provide an outline to help focus the discussion and our thoughts. Within each quadrant of the chart are several categories or spokes which are used as the actual quantifying system for each album. Along each spoke we come to an agreement on what feels right with positions further away from the center on any given spoke indicating a higher value for that given category. Below you can find a list of all the categories as well as the general concensus on what we used each spoke to measure.

Tone is used to describe how the actual sounds of piece of music enhance the depth and meaning behind the music. Is the artist using a particular style or instrument to elicit something from the listener? Does the tempo lend itself well to the pacing of the narrative? Questions like these are best answered with tone.

Theme is used to discuss important themes and recurring motifs within a piece of music. If the whole album is a scathing critique of the military-industrial complex, then it will be pretty thematically high.

Narrative is usually used to discuss the storytelling capacity of individual songs as well as overall albums

Lyricism is the most obvious of the four catergories within the depth quadrant. Are the lyrics good? Wow, pretty good lyricism them. Truthfully though, there's more nuance. Generally this category is also influenced by how important the lyrics are towards the experience of the album, and whether the lyrics are memorable, engaging, and meaningful

This applies to all of the emotion categories, but in order to avoid having a million different spokes in the emotion quadrant, we decided to break all emotion down into three basic components and can try to describe more complex feeings through a combination of multiple categories. Guilt may be described as a combination of angry and sad, bitter sweet obviously happy and sad, stuff like that. Happy is used as the primary metric to discuss upbeat, feelgood moments within the music.

This applies to all of the emotion categories, but in order to avoid having a million different spokes in the emotion quadrant, we decided to break all emotion down into three basic components and can try to describe more complex feeings through a combination of multiple categories. Guilt may be described as a combination of angry and sad, bitter sweet obviously happy and sad, stuff like that. Angry is used as the primary metric to discuss ravenous, fearful, and outwardly aggressive moments within the music.

This applies to all of the emotion categories, but in order to avoid having a million different spokes in the emotion quadrant, we decided to break all emotion down into three basic components and can try to describe more complex feeings through a combination of multiple categories. Guilt may be described as a combination of angry and sad, bitter sweet obviously happy and sad, stuff like that. Sad is used as the primary metric to discuss low, heavy, and difficult emotional moments within the music.

Passion is used to discuss the impact that the emotions within the music have on the energy. In application though, it's much easier to think of this categories as answerings both the questions "Does it feel like the artist really cares about what is being brought up in the song/the album as a whole?" and "How intensly does the artist protray emotion in the music?"

Je Ne Sais Quoi is used as a catch all for all the other qualities that leave a lasting impact on the listener and leave a piece often feeling memorable.

Tempo is used to discuss the actual and preceived speed of an album. Is the album slow and somber, or more lively and fast?

A more technical category (as you may notice to be the case with the majority of the categories in the sound quadrant), brightness is used to discuss the overall timbre of the music. High brightness albums may have qualifiers like metalic, sharp, or clear, while something with low brightness may istead be though of as dark, murky, or velvetty sounds.

EAM stands for Electronically Augmented Music and is used to describe the degree to which the music has been augmented with post processing, petals, or just electronic instruments like synths. Unlike other categories, this one is divided into three areas with the use of boxes. The lowest box usually describes primarily or all accoustic sounds and acapella. The middle box is where altered accoustic instruments live, like electric guitars or effect pedals. FInally, the topmost box is reserved to synth forward and electronic music.

Layering serves a dual function in discussions. Firstly it serves as a quantified measure of the amount of unique layers in a composition as well as the complexity of each. but crucially it is often used to describe the effectiveness of an artists layering approach. Some tones and emotions are strengthened by a sparser arangement and that effect is catptured on this spoke.

Grit is used to describe the texture and tactile quality of the music. Is is buttery smooth or a little cruncky? How harsh is the sound? Generally more abrasive genres like rock, punk, and metal, will end up higher on spoke just by the nature of the sound.

 


ARCHIVE



COMPARATIVE SEARCH FUNCTION


Click the button to sort the archive by your desired category:

Order Album Name Artist Release Year Genre Length Narrative Lyricism Happy Angry Sad Passion Je Ne Sais Quoi Tempo Brightness Electrometer Layering Grit Tone
001 Illinois Sufjan Stevens 2005 Closeted Geography 73:59 0.9546625 0.8787744 0.4080743 0.0339941 0.2033900 0.7633814 0.6436077 0.5075014 0.5861380 0.5026893 0.6884819 0.0421014 0.8393670
002 As It Ever Was, So it
Will Be Again
The Decemberists 2024 Folkloric Vigil 67:39 0.8989680 0.9486661 0.5858540 0.0067020 0.2478367 0.2889033 0.7396882 0.4910923 0.5281200 0.4625899 0.7478318 0.4297008 0.8217523
003 HIT ME HARD AND SOFT Billie Eilish 2024 Waterlogged Gay Pop 43:50 0.6949766 0.6735936 0.3996507 0.4709424 0.7401288 0.6824367 0.9058950 0.2543998 0.1791021 0.7120642 0.7526078 0.2588118 0.9612997
004 Zach Bryan Zach Bryan 2023 PTSD Americana 54:23 0.4371744 0.6500425 0.2201628 0.4999943 0.8528901 0.7502841 0.5203242 0.3180816 0.2568492 0.3349857 0.4039225 0.4527848 0.8312822
005 151a Kishi Bashi 2013 One Place, One Time, All Joy 34:22 0.1182870 0.0500941 0.8831629 0.0028124 0.1419182 0.7486623 0.6222357 0.7042779 0.9474663 0.5343531 0.7101283 0.0229607 0.6318417
006 Synthesizing: Ten Ragas
To a Disco Beat
Charanjit Singh 1982 Acid Bollywood Disco House 49:41 0.0416833 0.0076059 0.6755052 0.0043024 0.0105679 0.6149260 0.9353750 0.9496642 0.5541598 0.9887837 0.6497164 0.3289214 0.5112958
007 Evermore Taylor Swift 2020 Pandemic Piano Pop Folk 60:38 0.1660263 0.6551579 0.2772459 0.3631274 0.9167985 0.4550887 0.6386275 0.3209660 0.2305555 0.3221264 0.5076708 0.0501211 0.7568002
008 The Wall Pink Floyd 1979 Where Fame, Flaws, and Fascism meet 80:42 0.9904223 0.8386160 -0.0088636 0.8716801 0.4214642 0.5911136 0.9760494 0.5409981 0.1178201 0.4233725 0.8312797 0.6593956 0.9834063
009 Cosmogramma Flying Lotus 2010 Cosmic Mammmmmmmmmmmma 45:44 0.4582891 0.0677161 0.2306745 0.0154418 0.0720312 0.4099663 0.7095597 0.9469106 0.5210235 0.9945651 0.9945128 0.6015377 0.7352777
010 The Weather Pond 2017 Apocalyptic Psych Rock 43:53 0.4595538 0.8290387 0.0800480 0.4137968 0.2345456 0.6349350 0.4696300 0.5711201 0.6769943 0.6613924 0.7576005 0.1922574 0.8195128
011 Motewolonuwok Jeremy Dutcher 2023 A Bridge 48:03 0.4000000 0.4122588 0.3418110 0.1355810 0.8160524 0.8451539 0.6954134 0.0818464 0.2397021 0.0093097 0.2578343 0.0759027 0.6602355
012 Con Todo El Mundo Khruangbin 2018 Hazy Houston Hijinx 41:58 0.0602586 0.0387459 0.2605506 0.0052413 0.1715907 0.4865870 0.7496896 0.4753667 0.3140053 0.4302281 0.5098249 0.1566016 0.6636662
013a Kendrick v. Drake Beef Drake 2024 Beef 24:49 0.2943129 0.1572920 0.0005795 0.2882219 0.0716324 0.5567804 0.1921812 0.5143708 0.0200327 0.7412079 0.4238341 0.0510801 0.3399423
013b Kendrick v. Drake Beef Kendrick Lamar 2024 Beef 25:43 0.7189740 0.9827560 0.0460711 0.7569787 0.1738784 0.8526948 0.9005158 0.4785041 0.0773479 0.7412079 0.7720979 0.1330653 0.6935541
014 Harvest Neil Young 1972 Lonely Boy's Ranch Rock 37:27 0.1819067 0.7179642 0.0610082 0.2899346 0.4799447 0.2938034 0.5000822 0.2216751 0.2678631 0.1523203 0.1874745 0.3051891 0.8150619
015 Leon Leon Bridges 2024 DFVV 43:45 0.2500461 0.4818698 0.8058159 0.0052239 0.6768808 0.8665004 0.7150598 0.4935212 0.3063000 0.3903712 0.3439457 0.0063445 0.9314188
016 Honey Samia 2023 Tiny Sad Girl Soft Pop 40:06 0.2219063 0.3402137 0.4155236 0.5653077 0.7513457 0.3548085 0.4804233 0.3639888 0.3674970 0.6538860 0.3584847 0.0995556 0.6325588
017 Dunya Mustafa the Poet 2024 Fall in Gaza 40:50 0.5410996 0.9312309 0.0848287 0.4169501 0.7740546 0.6875355 0.8799470 0.2154562 0.0254433 0.3245031 0.8709974 0.1743772 0.8717500
018 Low Altitude Living Ocean Alley 2022 Oceania Rock 50:15 0.0489088 0.1643836 0.1735446 0.0339953 0.3780985 0.3943355 0.4630733 0.6161140 0.5552540 0.4950967 0.4714696 0.1800828 0.5985243
019 Leak 04-13 (Bait Ones) Jai Paul 2013 Electric Pre-cum 37:16 0.1209236 0.1288156 0.2962367 0.2192195 0.2915567 0.6277562 0.8660073 0.8391476 0.8422973 0.9502942 0.7750439 0.6710844 0.3869676
020 Is Satan Real? Church of the Cosmic Skull 2016 Cult? 38:18 0.4065813 0.6528775 0.0440329 0.1655759 0.0879261 0.6956162 0.4416421 0.4320434 0.6441840 0.4369342 0.3388203 0.4963026 0.4536148
021 Digital Nightmare TWRP 2024 Synthetic Sleeplessness 42:32 0.4778545 0.3678995 0.3889749 0.2078462 0.2500636 0.5686703 0.5439149 0.6197924 0.7098303 0.8092637 0.4636048 0.1542583 0.8345370
022 New Ancient Strings Toumani Diabate 1999 Grass Music 53:24 0.0030786 0.0027422 0.6897395 0.0022021 0.0027519 0.6287312 0.7662021 0.2154616 0.7326085 0.0007647 0.3985427 0.0328064 0.9580174
023 Talking Heads 77 Talking Heads 1977 Who Tells You What to Think? 38:57 0.1825310 0.3873854 0.3152535 0.2920089 0.0438084 0.1409886 0.7626933 0.6299601 0.6440115 0.5485367 0.5364440 0.4691776 0.5063719
024 Only God Was Above Us Vampire Weekend 2024 Subway Surfers: Piano & Existential Crisis DLC 47:14 0.5482016 0.8791471 0.0999909 0.0898563 0.6794460 0.7052637 0.4405965 0.5088562 0.6619296 0.4203958 0.4203958 0.6097756 0.8658229
025 GNX Kendrick Lamar 2024 Angry West Coast 44:20 0.4908001 0.8222320 0.3912176 0.6745728 0.0773136 0.9903098 0.7337511 0.6160175 0.5856697 0.7664091 0.4554611 0.4125769 0.7676247
026 Chromakopia Tyler, The Creator 2024 Clown Car on the Audubon 52:54 0.4908001 0.8156676 0.3107062 0.2991290 0.3107119 0.9782400 0.9828898 0.6686036 0.4837493 0.5694947 0.7216501 0.1086249 0.8563033
027 American Love Call Durand Jones & the Indications 2019 Retro Butter Slide 42:39 0.0893884 0.0793269 0.3065658 0.0228585 0.2849865 0.4822166 0.3244769 0.1916549 0.2151491 0.2095279 0.4157994 0.0066965 0.7701531
028 Fine Line Harry Styles 2019 Sad Sex Pop Rock 46:43 0.2048751 0.4100012 0.4911925 0.0066965 0.4779286 0.5934533 0.5792143 0.5075672 0.6049314 0.3583128 0.2557257 0.0330718 0.6358371
029 Transatlanticism Death Cab for Cutie 2003 Not So Happy New Year 45:43 0.6180934 0.5695870 0.0845385 0.1803527 0.8800008 0.7251542 0.3142292 0.1077196 0.0284359 0.5111144 0.2216939 0.2618645 0.8050006
030 Jackman. Jack Harlow 2023 Participation Trophy 24:08 0.1605878 0.2069177 0.0442278 0.0992652 0.1287982 0.4209724 0.4157424 0.3356611 0.2691104 0.6121199 0.8102601 0.1865063 0.3984649
031 BRAT Charli XCX 2024 Bratpop 41:30 0.6788788 0.6559092 0.2561500 0.0937544 0.3591787 0.8166136 0.9860734 0.8761172 0.6146963 0.9447216 0.5095225 0.4938737 0.9822477
032 Toxicity System of a Down 2001 Baby Metal 44:01 0.3251936 0.6091020 0.1125741 0.9306644 0.4286300 0.8092566 0.6400627 0.8855733 0.0775681 0.5037930 0.1304154 0.9024333 0.8345761
033 Bewitched Laufey 2023 Laufey Love 48:27 0.5565337 0.4867821 0.1532808 0.0561077 0.5348266 0.6862890 0.7724138 0.2405497 0.3537558 0.1594028 0.2018472 -0.0042447 0.9585469
034 Untourable Album Men I Trust 2021 Soft Feminine Computer Music 43:26 0.1946485 0.3528696 0.3832571 0.0105200 0.4513508 0.4169578 0.5134400 0.3673152 0.2403773 0.5849686 0.5325615 0.0333033 0.9347389
035 Calypso Harry Belafonte 1956 King of Calypso 31:51 0.0974692 0.2159857 0.8772300 0.0253005 0.1542016 0.2297971 0.4666135 0.3916910 0.5540631 0.0799400 0.0916768 0.1391763 0.2885179
036 The Rise and Fall of a Midewest Princess Chappell Roan 2023 Super Graphic Ultra Modern Girl 49:08 0.4421951 0.5105550 0.5687409 0.5847257 0.6189543 0.8256138 0.9018735 0.4497163 0.4091060 0.7127153 0.3081351 0.0939462 0.5890095
037 West of it All Briscoe 2023 Hill Country Folk 37:56 0.2434493 0.4442158 0.6367521 0.0305480 0.3869998 0.5179084 0.5351013 0.4480271 0.6264165 0.2048823 0.3629588 0.4137748 0.9617042
038 Paranoid Black Sabbath 1970 The Template 41:48 0.3099114 0.6418321 0.0050382 0.7152274 0.7020985 0.5662511 0.8353891 0.4105877 0.1642383 0.5527448 0.3434750 0.7611376 0.6946456
039 Hugo Loyle Carner 2022 Dad Who Stepped Up 34:05 0.6335349 0.8119709 0.4524032 0.3850711 0.3857695 0.6825553 0.5878219 0.4460398 0.5106276 0.6374672 0.4324487 0.1770658 0.5978404
040 22, A Million Bon Iver 2016 Steamtune Folk 34:11 0.1818931 0.4253014 0.0085193 0.2119869 0.7761178 0.6933028 0.7731806 0.4851247 0.3214831 0.8203047 0.6250806 0.5889983 0.9461948
041 Manning Fireworks MJ Lenderman 2024 Lowkey Cowboy 38:54 0.5676762 0.6986162 0.0462256 0.0898610 0.4379328 0.4611433 0.5811258 0.4876957 0.1853917 0.3513393 0.2364548 0.0783700 0.6437684
042 The Girl, the Cat, And the Tree Lausse the Cat 2018 NSFW Storybook 21:55 0.7811534 0.4691119 0.0801854 0.0599490 0.0734083 0.4454261 0.6431202 0.5247543 0.3852126 0.6505887 0.4202974 0.3212709 0.7859760
043 I Feel Alive TOPS 2020 Gloss 35:18 0.0977842 0.2668457 0.7151619 0.0082001 0.1806043 0.6251964 0.5466574 0.5261017 0.4707596 0.6816316 0.5281864 0.0706828 0.7012519
044 Oh, Inverted World The Shins 2001 Honorary PNW 33:29 0.0954739 0.6134496 0.2911099 0.0140803 0.4288142 0.4874545 0.4874545 0.4623582 0.4121693 0.3170374 0.6069764 0.1691367 0.5053271
045 Discovery Daft Punk 2001 Montage.exe 60:50 0.0470865 0.0361542 0.6750591 0.0000084 0.0862653 0.4616250 0.8331582 0.6372657 0.6164671 0.8880662 0.5950819 0.1841385 0.4033665
046 The Man from Waco Charley Crockett 2022 Balcones Ballads 44:56 0.8858811 0.6420115 0.1560495 0.1696492 0.3744591 0.4200723 0.5451249 0.4091858 0.3088586 0.1803584 0.4203605 0.0789911 0.8832314
047 Overkill Motörhead 1979 Ladies, Rock & Roll, Motorcycle, & Horses 34:45 0.0320168 0.1950931 0.0884538 0.8178231 0.0683356 0.6699786 0.6188633 0.9252719 0.5864294 0.5543623 0.2741286 0.6573591 0.8137749
048 Room 25 Noname 2018 Professor Pu**y 34:48 0.2380709 0.8103421 0.1440689 0.2478237 0.0686680 0.3737105 0.7354758 0.5508089 0.4872160 0.4160348 0.4372365 0.1776826 0.5615463
049 Bloodless Samia 2025 Mosquito-core 40:32 0.3912288 0.8549723 0.0995027 0.3454618 0.8202562 0.6367297 0.6527921 0.4796067 0.0385430 0.3054009 0.4455214 0.2073513 0.8917048
050 Natural Light Dan Mangan 2025 You Just Need a Cabin to get Back to Your Roots 45:13 0.2841943 0.8131300 0.3851208 0.1389241 0.3139223 0.7136002 0.3625818 0.3389383 0.4778716 0.2476803 0.3498445 0.1258916 0.8338595
051 Lotus Little Simz 2025 It Feels Very Phoenix-esque 49:55 0.4321287 0.7460143 0.4522979 0.8236993 0.6667102 0.8296687 0.7572814 0.5490982 0.4124651 0.6253859 0.6221431 0.2454487 0.8126985

All album covers collected for this archive using this website
Please don't sue.


FAQ


Hi all, thanks for making your way all the way to the bottom of my friends and I little website!

Currently this section doesn't have a lot of information, but if you have any questions, comments, or recommendations

please leave them in the text box below and hopefully we'll be able to take a look at it!

NOTE: I'M STILL TRYING TO FIGURE THE FUNCTIONALITY OUT!!!! IF YOU HAVE COMMENTS, PLEASE LEAVE THEM AS POSTS ON OUR PROFILE PAGE. WE APPOLOGIZE FOR THE DELAY!